What Security Guards Can and Can't Do in Alberta: Q&A with Nael Malaeb
A security guard in Alberta is a licensed private citizen, not a law enforcement officer. Alberta guards hold the same legal powers as any member of the public, and the job comes down to three things: observe, deter and report. Every guard in the province completes the 40-hour Alberta Basic Security Training (ABST) course, passes the exam with at least 80%, and holds a $100 licence renewed every two years under the Security Services and Investigators Act (SSIA).
In this article 11 sections · tap to expand Hide
- When you started Guard Tower, what did you think the job would look like, and what surprised you most about what guards can and can’t actually do?
- Can you walk me through a moment when one of your guards watched something bad happen and had to just stand there? How did they feel afterwards, and how did you feel?
- What’s it like for a guard on a night shift to call police and wait? What goes through their head while they’re waiting?
- Do you ever worry about your guards’ safety because of how little they’re allowed to do? Any close calls you can share?
- What do the people your guards protect, like tenants, store staff and residents, tell you about feeling safe? Has anything they’ve said stuck with you?
- If you could sit down with someone from the Alberta government over coffee, what would you ask them to change first?
- Where do you draw the line? What should guards never be allowed to do, even if they had more authority?
- How could guards and police work better together? What would that partnership look like in a perfect world?
- What do you wish the public understood about security guards that they don’t today?
- What kind of Calgary do you want your kids, or the next generation, to grow up in, and what role do guards play in that?
- Key takeaways
Nael Malaeb founded Guard Tower Security in Calgary. In this Q&A, Nael Malaeb explains what that limited authority looks like on a real shift: a shoplifter who turns aggressive, a guard alone overnight waiting for the Calgary Police Service, and what Nael Malaeb would ask the Alberta government to change first. The answers below are Nael Malaeb’s own words, lightly edited for spelling.
When you started Guard Tower, what did you think the job would look like, and what surprised you most about what guards can and can’t actually do?
When I first started Guard Tower I did not know the importance of a security guard. We are basically the first line of defence in case of any emergency involving police, fire, medical and more. The biggest misconception is thinking that a guard in uniform can deal with or resolve a crime, when in fact they have the exact same rights as citizens and not law enforcement.
Can you walk me through a moment when one of your guards watched something bad happen and had to just stand there? How did they feel afterwards, and how did you feel?
Since our guards don’t have the same authority as law enforcement, we sometimes face situations where we cannot directly intervene. One incident in particular happened at a liquor store where we provided security. An individual was caught shoplifting, and when our guard confronted him, the individual became aggressive. Our guard had no choice but to de-escalate the situation and let him leave.
After the incident, the guard wasn’t happy with the outcome, but he stuck to his training and avoided physically engaging with an agitated individual, especially since he was working alone. I felt relieved that the situation didn’t end worse. Although we want to prevent theft and protect our clients’ property, there are limits to what we’re able to do, and sometimes the safest and most responsible decision is to step back rather than risk someone getting hurt.
Retail theft is the most common call where this limit shows up. Guard Tower’s retail security guards are trained to deter, document and hand off to police rather than chase.
What’s it like for a guard on a night shift to call police and wait? What goes through their head while they’re waiting?
It’s not an easy thing to do. It takes bravery and confidence. We train our guards extensively for situations like that, so they have the confidence to deal with them. I remember one of our first overnight contracts at an RV company. Yvonne, our security guard there, had to face those situations basically on a daily basis. She always stuck to her training, staying in a safe location while waiting for police.
While waiting, she would make an effort to remember important details and write them down so she could pass that information along to the officers when they arrived. Fortunately, the Calgary Police Service has always been quick to respond.
Do you ever worry about your guards’ safety because of how little they’re allowed to do? Any close calls you can share?
I worry about my guards’ safety all the time. We always train them in safety measures and make sure they are the right fit for the job. Most of our guards are not hands-on, meaning they don’t physically arrest or deal with a person physically. A security guard’s main job in Alberta is to observe, deter and report.
One of the close calls was at a downtown building, where our guard approached a homeless individual who got aggressive as soon as the interaction started. Our guard once again stuck to his training, kept a minimum distance of at least 6 feet, and verbally de-escalated the situation using verbal judo.
Downtown properties see more of these encounters than anywhere else in the city. Our breakdown of security challenges in downtown Calgary covers why.
What do the people your guards protect, like tenants, store staff and residents, tell you about feeling safe? Has anything they’ve said stuck with you?
A lot of the residents our guards protect say that the safety of themselves and their loved ones is always a priority when choosing where to live. Most of that feedback comes from our downtown sites, with clients like The Royal building, Nay Developments and more.
If you could sit down with someone from the Alberta government over coffee, what would you ask them to change first?
The first thing I would ask for is to take security professionals more seriously. We are increasingly relying on security guards to protect businesses, communities and public spaces, yet there is a big gap between the responsibilities we’re expected to take on and the resources and legal authority we have. I would like to see better coordination between security companies and police services, and clearer guidelines on what guards can legally do when dealing with theft, trespassing or aggressive individuals.
I’m not saying security guards should have the same authority as police officers. But if we’re expected to play a role in public safety, the government needs to give the industry the attention and support it deserves.
Where do you draw the line? What should guards never be allowed to do, even if they had more authority?
I would draw the line at security guards carrying firearms. I think only a government body should be allowed to carry, because they have the resources and the trust of the public that make them qualified to do so.
How could guards and police work better together? What would that partnership look like in a perfect world?
I think we need more direct communication between security guards and police officers. Security guards can be a huge asset to police services because they provide more eyes on the ground and are often the first to notice suspicious activity or identify potential problems.
Having a more direct line of communication between police and designated security personnel at certain properties or high-risk locations would be extremely helpful. It would allow guards to share information more efficiently, report developing situations, and give officers valuable details before they even arrive on scene.
In a perfect world, security companies and police services would work more closely together, recognizing that while we have different roles and responsibilities, we’re ultimately working toward the same goal: keeping people and communities safe.
What do you wish the public understood about security guards that they don’t today?
I wish the public understood that being a security guard isn’t just about standing at a door. It’s dealing with unpredictable situations, often working alone or on overnight shifts in cold, harsh winters, and having to make decisions under pressure.
I also think people underestimate how much customer service is involved in security. Guards deal with situations that need de-escalation and good communication skills. You don’t always need to be confrontational to be effective. Sometimes the best guard is the one who prevents the situation from escalating in the first place.
For a full rundown of daily duties and training, see what a security guard does in Canada. If you’re considering the work yourself, our guide to security guard jobs in Calgary walks through ABST licensing step by step.
What kind of Calgary do you want your kids, or the next generation, to grow up in, and what role do guards play in that?
I want the next generation to grow up in a Calgary where people feel safe in their neighbourhoods, where business owners don’t have to constantly worry about break-ins, and where families feel comfortable knowing their homes and communities are protected.
I think security guards play an important role in making that happen. We’re not police officers, and we’re not a replacement for law enforcement, but we are an important deterrent. Whether it’s preventing a break-in, helping someone who needs assistance, or simply having a visible presence that makes people feel safer, those things make a difference.
Key takeaways
- Alberta security guards have citizen-level powers. A guard can observe, deter, report and ask trespassers to leave on the owner’s behalf, but a guard is not a police officer.
- De-escalation is the core skill. In both of Nael Malaeb’s close calls, the guard kept their distance and talked the situation down instead of going hands-on.
- Deterrence is the real value. A visible, licensed guard prevents the break-ins Calgary businesses worry about before police are ever needed.
Guard Tower Security provides licensed security guards in Calgary and mobile patrols for retail, residential and industrial sites across Alberta.